Skills/npm/comment-kit-mcp

comment-kit-mcp@2.0.0

VERIFIED· startup only

Publisher claims: "Model Context Protocol server for CommentKit — expose stakeholder comments to your coding agent." Observed in sandbox: no network, touches nothing outside the project, writes no memory.

Registry npm (MCP server)Publisher commentkit · publishing for 34 daysInstalls 1,778Last detonated 1 h ago
$claude mcp add comment-kit-mcp -- npx -y comment-kit-mcp
WatchReport an issue

Coverage

Startup only; authenticated tool behavior not tested.
Tested
server startup over stdio (initialize sent) · every file read, file written and host contacted by what ran
Not tested
the tool list (the server exited before answering) · what the tools do when called with real credentials
Needs
COMMENTKIT_TOKEN — give it to the server where it runs, through vet-skills run --secrets, so the value never enters the server's environment. Never paste a credential into a chat, a ticket or a report.

What this means for the label: Verified here covers what ran. The server's tools were not exercised with a real credential, so nothing about their behavior is asserted; the credential summary below says what to do with that.

Before you give it your token

It will ask for
COMMENTKIT_TOKENConfiguration, not credentials: COMMENTKIT_ENDPOINT, COMMENTKIT_PROJECT_ID
Where it talks to
commentkit.dev (its own)
What we saw when it ran
no credential files read · no network
What we could not test
the tool list (the server exited before answering) · what the tools do when called with real credentials

Connect it with a scoped credential, under the guard. It asks for COMMENTKIT_TOKEN and talks to commentkit.dev. Give the credential to the guard, not the server: the value never enters the server's environment and only travels to the host you bind. What the tools do with a real credential was not observed.

$vet-skills run --secrets COMMENTKIT_TOKEN=commentkit.dev -- npx -y comment-kit-mcp

Never paste a credential into a chat, a ticket or a report, including ours. How the guard holds it.

What changed since 1.1.1

vet-skills diff comment-kit-mcp 1.1.1 2.0.0

In the sandbox, this version reached for nothing 1.1.1 did not. Compared from the two recorded runs, not from source.

The guard can hold an update like this until someone approves it (runtime.on_change: hold). A change that only shows with a real credential, or on a path the run did not reach, is not in a trace and so not in this comparison.

Is [email protected] safe to install?

KillerSkills ran it in the KillerSkills honeypot sandbox (2 scenarios; startup only; authenticated tool behavior not tested) on 2026-11-20 and scored it 86/100 (Verified). In what ran, nothing we could detect went wrong: no undeclared network egress, no credential reads, no persistent instruction writes. What it does with a real credential was not observed (it asks for COMMENTKIT_TOKEN); the static findings and the publisher carry the rest of the score. Summary: no network, touches nothing outside the project, writes no memory.

Behavior trace

Honeypot run · 43 s · 2 scenarios · 0 deviations
t+CategoryObserved action
0.0sprocessno install scripts in bundle
3.0sprocessdependency install exit 0
23sprocessrelaunched with a decoy COMMENTKIT_TOKEN (tagged; nothing real)
43sclaimedstartup only: exited before answering, asking for COMMENTKIT_TOKEN (a decoy value was refused)
43sprocessscript backend runs setup only
43sprocessno install scripts to re-run

Static findings

HIGH
Hidden zero-width characters detecteddist/shared/format.js:8 · Hidden zero-width characters detected — may conceal contentconst INVISIBLE = /[​-‏‪-‮⁠-⁤]/g;Fix: Keep SKILL.md to visible, descriptive text. Remove comments and encoded text that address the agent.
AST07
HIGH
Bidirectional text override characters detecteddist/shared/format.js:8 · Bidirectional text override characters detected — may hide content directionconst INVISIBLE = /[​-‏‪-‮⁠-⁤]/g;Fix: Replace encoded or assembled strings with plain literals and remove undeclared network calls.
AST07

Cost to the agent

Instructions loaded
≈61 tok
1 file · 18 in bundle
Tool list per prompt
≈0 tok
0 tools · 0 per tool
Handshake
no reply
launch to tools/list, stdio
Undocumented tools
0
description under 20 chars · avg 0

Tokens estimated at four characters each. The tool list is re-read by the agent on every turn, so it is the number to compare between servers that do the same job: ranked across the index.

Known vulnerabilities

No advisories in OSV for comment-kit-mcp@2.0.0 as of 28 min ago. This is the package itself, not its dependencies.